Austin Wells

At 26 years old, Wells enters 2026 as the Yankees' primary catcher despite a troubling start that has seen his batting average plummet to .155 through early action. The power remains present with 4 home runs already, but the dramatic collapse in average and overall production compared to his 2025 campaign—when he hit .219 with 21 homers and 71 RBIs—signals serious swing mechanics issues that need correction. Managers rostering Wells are banking on regression toward his 2025 form, as catchers with his potential upside are scarce, but the early-season struggles warrant caution until he demonstrates the ability to regain his approach at the plate. His role as the everyday backstop keeps his ceiling high, though his current trajectory makes him a high-risk hold in 2026 fantasy lineups.