Mickey Gasper

At 30 years old, this backstop continues to struggle at the plate after a rough 2025 campaign, carrying a concerning .243 average through early 2026 with minimal power production and zero home runs so far. The lack of offensive output in both batting average and power categories makes him a risky fantasy play in most formats, as catcher is already a shallow position and his limited RBI and run-scoring opportunities offer little compensation. While his brief All-Star selection in the minors showed promise years ago, the transition to MLB has been disappointing, and fantasy managers would be better served searching for more productive options at the position unless he shows a significant turnaround in performance.