Tyler Stephenson

Entering his seventh season in the majors, this Cincinnati backstop continues to display modest offensive production that limits his fantasy appeal in most formats. His 2026 start reflects a concerning decline in power output—dropping from 13 home runs last season to just 6 through 200 at-bats—while his batting average remains stuck in the low-.220s, offering little help in that critical category. The lack of stolen base activity and middling run production further restrict his upside, making him a depth catcher at best in redraft leagues. Fantasy managers should view him as a streaming option or bench backup rather than a reliable weekly contributor, as his role and production remain unconvincing even after establishing himself as a regular in the Cincinnati lineup.